Whether you have spent countless months growing the perfect, bushy beard or you are simply shaving what has grown in the last few days, shaving is no small matter. You need to keep in mind that shaving is never simply shaving.
If you want to be sure that you have a comfortable post shave face, I would recommend looking into an after shave balm to use. Now, there are a lot of after shave balms out there, but the key is finding the one that is best for you.
Now, when it comes to choosing a balm, there are many options to consider.
Choosing the right aftershave
- The controversy surrounding aftershave in general:
It’s not uncommon to hear of a man who doesn’t use any type of aftershave, balm or otherwise. While it’s every person’s choice as to whether or not they want to use some type of aftershave, it really is best to use it.
One of the biggest reasons people believe that aftershave is no beneficial and that they shouldn’t use it is because of the burning sensation they receive from the alcohol in the products. Though the burning sensation is never enjoyable and it turns many away from using it, the benefits that come after the burning are far better than not using any aftershave at all.
- Aftershave lotion VS aftershave balm:
Now, if you are of the opinion that maybe you should use a lotion rather than a balm, you might consider something else. Lotions typically have the alcohol in them that I mentioned above, thus causing the burning sensation. However, the balms don’t tend to have any alcohol in them which means they won’t burn when applied
The benefits of after shave balm:
You might be thinking that spending your money on a balm for when you are done shaving is simply a waste of money. I mean, is there really any benefit to using the balm? You might be surprised to learn that using a balm after shaving is actually very beneficial for helping to soothe your just shaved skin which has a tendency to get irritated.
It also adds moisture to the skin and revitalizes it. Overall, it will help keep your skin very healthy. If you are not completely convinced, check out this short video that explains why it is the best choice and how to apply it once you have finished shaving.
- How to choose the right balm:
If you have decided to use after shave balm, I would highly recommend doing extensive research on the different types that are on the market. Not every balm has the same ingredients and not every balm has the same level of quality. Don’t let your search be influenced by the price either. You want a balm that will work well and actually be worth your money, so don’t be afraid to spend a little more money on one that will actually do what it’s supposed to do.
Like I said above, not every balm will be the same, so be aware of what you are wanting in a balm before you buy. There are a lot of great brands out there, but they won’t all be great for everyone. Research the ‘type’ of benefits you want from your after shave balm. Some might have sensitive skin, so they need a balm that won’t irritate their skin. Others might want one that has anti-bacterial benefits. It all depends on your need. Check out this link for a few different types of balm.
Products we reviewed for the best aftershave balm
Products to consider
When it comes to choosing your specific product there are more aftershave balms than you can imagine. Below I have made a list of 13 top quality aftershave balms to consider.
Taylor of Old Bond Street Aftershave Balm, 2.5-Ounce
$22.82 in stock
Features
- Soothing aftershave balm contains aloe and witch hazel to soothe and condition skin after shaving
- Contains witch hazel to help coax pores closed
- Aftershave Balm, alcohol free with aloe vera to soothe and witch hazel to help coax pores closed.
- Alchohol free
This brand helps close your pores quickly while giving a soothing after affect with no burning sensation.
Pros We Like
- Penetrates your skin quite well and leaves no residue behind.
- Beneficial toward razor burn.
- It has a pleasant scent.
- It does not irritate sensitive skin.
- Does not leave you feeling too greasy.
- Gives your face a refreshed feeling.
- The balm lasts a long time.
- Does a great job of moisturizing the skin.
Cons We Dont Like
- The scent only makes it through half of the day.
- It’s a little expensive.
- It’s quite liquidy so can be difficult to handle.
- It may cause some irritation to those with sensitive skin.
L'Occitane Soothing Cade After Shave Balm for Men with Shea Butter, 2.5 Fl Oz
Features
- Helps resist redness, razor burn and feelings of tightness; purifies skin to clean and soothe nicks and breakouts^Apply to face and neck after shaving, paying close attention to irritated areas
Pros We Like
- Leaves your face feeling nice and smooth.
- It has a pleasant scent.
- The scent is not overwhelming.
- The balm lasts a long time.
- Helps relieve the burn caused by shaving.
- Helps to moisturize skin.
Cons We Dont Like
- Not the best product for anyone with super sensitive skin.
- The scent does not last as long as preferred.
- Some claim that it requires a lot of product each use in order to be effective.
- It’s quite expensive.
- Leaves a gooey residue on your face.
- Doesn’t handle irritation as well as other products.
Aramis Advanced Moisturizing After Shave Balm For Men 4.10 oz
Features
- ARAMIS by Aramis Advanced Moisturizing After Shave Balm 4.1 oz for Men
A casual wear brand, this aftershave balm is known to be high quality balm because they claim it is made from materials that are high quality. It contains many rich spices and oils that create a pleasant scent and experience.
Pros We Like
- A little bit of balm goes a long way.
- It leaves the skin feeling soft and healthy.
- The balm isn’t too pricey.
- Helps soothe your skin after shaving.
Cons We Dont Like
- The scent may be a bit too strong.
Proraso After Shave Balm, Protective and Moisturizing, 3.4 Fl Oz
Features
- After Shave Balm moisturizes and strengthens your skin
- Reduces redness and improves skin tone
- Natural-based formulation without mineral oils or artificial colors
- Alcohol free, no parabens, no silicons, no mineral oil
- Made in Italy
Pros We Like
- A little bit of product goes a long way.
- It works well with sensitive skin.
- Does well with benefiting and moisturizing irritated skin after shaving.
- Your skin isn’t left feeling greasy.
- Has a nice, manly scent.
- Doesn’t sting upon application.
- Helps stop breakouts caused by shaving.
Cons We Dont Like
- The bottle (since it doesn’t have a pump) makes getting the balm out a bit challenging.
- There can be issues with consistency.
- The scent doesn’t last very long.
- A bit on the pricey side.
Baxter of California Men's After Shave Balm for Men | Cooling Sensation | 4 fl. Oz
Features
- Enriched with aloe vera and allantoin
- Prevents ingrown hairs
- Soothes and comforts Your skin
This brand of aftershave balm contains no alcohol and leaves your skin feeling cool and nourished. It helps protect from any post shave irritation or dryness.
Pros We Like
- Hydrates your skin without leaving it feeling greasy.
- Works with those with sensitive skin.
- Leaves your skin feeling cool and revitalized.
- The product last a long time.
- Heals shaving cuts and irritation nicely.
Cons We Dont Like
- Some issues with consistency.
- A bit pricey for the amount that you receive.
- There some issues with the scent.
- Doesn’t work well with oily skin.
- Occasional issues with not moisturizing as much as it advertises.
Natural Lavender Aftershave Balm with Aromatherapy Grade Lavender, by Gilbert Henry. Paraben-Free and No Synthetics. Non-Greasy, Ultra Soothing Formula. Made in The U.S.A. 4 fl oz.
Features
- MODERN - The latest in natural skincare eliminates razor burn and redness. Aloe Juice, Coconut Oil, Vegetable Glycerine moisturize your skin. Witch Hazel, Black Willowbank Extract and Neem oil to heal and protect.
- SOPHISTICATED - Fragrance formula designed using the techniques of fine perfumery and only the highest quality essential oil.
- UNIQUE - The fragrance is composed only of natural French Lavender, harvested and distilled at high altitudes (and low temperatures) to preserve the masculine characteristics of this classic barbershop scent.
- PRACTICAL - Includes a convenient pump-top that allows you to dispense the perfect amount each time, with no mess. Two or three pumps is enough, so one bottle will last for months!
- CONFIDENT - We’re sure you’ll love this balm, but we'll refund your purchase if it doesn't meet your highest expectations!
This modern brand of aftershave balm is beneficial for any type of burn, irritation, or redness caused by shaving. The scent is sophisticated and unique.
Pros We Like
- Has a pleasant fragrance.
- Leaves your skin feeling refreshed.
- Doesn’t leave your skin feeling greasy.
- Does not have a burning sensation when applied.
- Helps soothe your skin after shaving.
- Works well with sensitive skin.
- Speeds up the healing process of rashes, nicks, etc.
- A little bit of balm goes a long way.
Cons We Dont Like
- Some find the scent to be overpowering.
Bath & Body Works C.O. Bigelow No.1401 Bay Rum After-Shave Balm 3.4 fl oz/100ml
Features
- Brand New,Never Opened and Never Used.
- Plastic Bottle and not in box (New Style)
- Calming & Cooling Green Tea, Aloe Vera, Cucumber, Chamomile, Grape Seed Extract, & Shea Butter
- Warm and Exotic Fragrance Masterfully Blends Bay Oil, Citrus and Spices
- C.O. Bigelow Apothecaries Collection.A Timeless Favorite Through The Decades.
This quality product contains a pleasant mixture of oils to give a nice warm scent and a combination of ingredients that give your skin a calm cool feeling.
Pros We Like
- Has a wonderful scent.
- Helps stop breakouts caused by shaving.
Cons We Dont Like
- It is a bit on the pricey side.
Soap Commander Aftershave Balm with Menthol (Integrity - Unscented)
Features
- Perfect for those with sensitive skin or fragrance allergies
- Hint of menthol provides a refreshing cooling sensation to complete your shave
- Super moisturizing to heal skin after shaving
This brand contains Shea butter, oils known for nourishing, and a little bit of menthol. They also pack a powerful, but pleasant, punch of scents including bits of pineapple, water lily, peppermint, honeydew, black currant, and citrus.
Pros We Like
- It doesn’t make your face feel greasy.
- The scent, though pleasant, does not overwhelm you in a negative way.
- The cooling sensation created by the menthol is quite pleasant.
- The balm causes fewer break outs after shaving.
- Your skin is left feeling refreshed.
- The ingredients they use are all natural.
- You don’t need to use as much balm per use compared to other balms, thus making the tube last longer.
Cons We Dont Like
- It applies to your face a little drier than other balms.
- The quantity is smaller than might be preferred.
- The scent doesn’t last as long as it is advertised.
Truefitt & Hill Aftershave Balm- 1805 (3.38oz)
Features
- CLASSIC AFTERSHAVE BALM: A rich, soothing moisturiser that contains lanolin and aloe vera extract, scented with the 1805 bouquet. Suitable for all skin types and specially formulated for gentlemen with sensitive skin. Apply a small amount of the aftershave balm into hands and massage into the face and neck area after shaving.
- 1805: A fresh oceanic fragrance with top notes of Bergamot, Mandarin and Cardamon, combined with a Lavender, Geranium and Clary Sage heart resting on a Sandalwood, Cedar Wood and Musk base.
- HISTORY: Truefitt is mentioned throughout modern English literature as a bastion of style and the highest quality service - a tradition we are proud to continue today.
- GROOMED TO PERFECTION: Our products are formulated with an exquisite blend of rare, natural and sophisticated essences. Our offering includes a full line of shaving, fragrance, hair and bath products to provide a daily grooming solution for the modern man.
- TRUEFITT & HILL: Recognised as the finest traditional gentlemen's barber and perfumer in London, has provided discerning gentlemen with only the finest in grooming products and services.
This brand helps your skin feel soothed and refreshed. It is classic and lively while also leaving your skin refreshed.
Pros We Like
- It works well with sensitive skin.
- Has a pleasant scent that is not overpowering.
- Does not irritate your skin.
Cons We Dont Like
- It is a bit on the expensive side.
Calvin Klein OBSESSION for Men After Shave Balm, 5 Fl Oz
Features
- Launched by the design house of Calvin Klein in 1986
- It is classified as a flowery fragrance
- This masculine scent possesses a blend of mandarin and spice, with low tones of musk, sandalwood, and amber
- Packaging for this product may vary from that shown in the image above
You are quite likely familiar the brand called Calvin Klein. Their version of aftershave balm contains a blend of rare woods and botanics that create a pleasant aroma.
Pros We Like
- The balm has a pleasant citrus aroma.
- There is no burning feeling when it is applied.
- Caters well to the users with sensitive skin.
- It helps to soften you skin.
- The bottle lasts a long time.
- The fragrance does not fade quickly.
- It has a pleasant but subtle fragrance.
- It is not as messy as the splash on aftershave products.
- It is very beneficial for helping the irritation of razor burn.
- It only requires small dab of the balm to be effective.
Cons We Dont Like
- It is a bit pricier than other balms.
- There are occasional packing and shipping issues.
Caswell-Massey Eucalyptus After Shave Balm – Soothing Aftershave With Jojoba And Shea, Made In USA, 4 Ounces
Features
- EUCALYPTUS AFTER SHAVE – This soothing after shave balm contains Jojoba Oil, Shea Butter, Sea Kelp, Chamomile, Grapeseed and Eucalyptus Extract.
- GREAT FOR YOUR SKIN – Use this premium after shave when you are finished shaving to soothe, calm and moisturize your skin. It will help heal razor burns, nicks and irritation.
- LIGHT MANLY FRAGRANCE – The eucalyptus after shave leaves behind a subtle, minty fragrance. This pleasant, manly scent is sure to be a crowd pleaser.
- CRUELTY-FREE PRODUCTION – Caswell-Massey produces this high-quality after shave without the use of animal testing. It contains no parabens, sulfates or phthalates.
- MADE IN THE USA – Caswell-Massey, an American Original, has been producing luxury Soaps and Fine Fragrances for over 266 years, since being founded in America in 1752.
This brand of balm is free of sufate, phthalate, and paraben. It is also not tested on animals. It contains ingredients like shea butter and jojoba oil and they use scents like grape seed, chamomile, and eucalyptus.
Pros We Like
- The scent is not too powerful.
- Quickly heals any burn caused by shaving.
- It is very soothing.
- Scent of eucalyptus opens up your sinuses.
- Hydrates your face and neck.
Cons We Dont Like
- The absorption isn’t very quick.
- Can become greasy if not used moderately.
Aftershave Lotion For Men - (5oz) Mens Anti-Aging Post Shave Moisturizer With Vitamin E - Unscented After Shave Lotion With Cooling Menthol - Prevent & Heal Razor Burn and Dry Skin With Moisturizing S
Features
- ♦ Why It's Great - Our anti-aging and cooling aftershave lotion is full of the highest quality, natural ingredients. It absorbs quickly to leave your face moisturized but not greasy.
- ♦ Who It's Great For - Because it's unscented this premium after shave lotion is perfect for any man who wants the best ingredients without nasty synthetic fragrances, fillers, or harmful chemicals.
- ♦ Why It Works - Packed with Vitamin E, a well known antioxidant and a touch of menthol to cool and refresh. Got razor burn, a nick, or a cut? Shea butter will decrease healing time. Vitamin E also slows the skin’s aging process.
- ♦ Unscented Awesomeness - We don't include any synthetic fragrances. Only the purest, highest quality ingredients are allowed in our jars, so you can feel confident about enjoying the best post shave experience possible. As always, non-comedogenic for your moisturizing pleasure.
- ♦ You'll Freaking Love it Or It's Free - Musk & Hustle stands behind our Zero Musk line of men's grooming products 150%. If you don't love the way your face feels while using this aftershave lotion we'll give you a 100% full, no questions asked refund.
The brand of aftershave balm is packed with the antioxidant Vitamin E which helps to heal any cuts and burns much faster. Vitamin E also helps slow the aging of the skin. It also contains Shea butter which helps the healing process as well.
Pros We Like
- It is not considered greasy when applied.
- It absorbs into the skin well.
- It is great for eliminating razor burn.
- The ingredients soothe the skin well.
- The lack of fragrance is great because it doesn’t interfere with your choice of cologne.
- It helps moisturize your skin.
- Having the product in the jar ensures that you can use all of the product (as opposed to a tube).
- Works well with sensitive skin.
Cons We Dont Like
- Consistency is too liquidy.
- Because of the lack of thickness, it can be easy to be wasteful with the product.
Health & Beauty Dead Sea Minerals After Shave Balm for Men 150ml
$19.75 in stock
Features
- AFTERSHAVE BALM: The aftershave for men contains a combination of Dead Sea minerals and natural plant extracts that moisturize and protect the skin. The lotion for men works to hydrate and smooth inflamed areas that are irritated by shaving. It effectively improves redness and soreness. The face moisturizer for men has a light and non-greasy formula which absorbs quickly without leaving residue.
- DEAD SEA MINERALS: The men’s face lotion contains Dead Sea minerals from the Jordan valley. Dead Sea mud contains high concentrations of up to 26 different beneficial minerals such as sodium, potassium and magnesium. It has been used for centuries to alleviate dry skin conditions. The after shave balm for men nourishes the skin and provides hydration, whilst encouraging blood circulation and repair.
- PLANT EXTRACTS: The shaving kit for men contains Aloe Vera which rejuvenates the skin and prevents dryness. It forms a protective barrier to lock in moisture and prevent environmental damage. The shave oil contains Vitamins A and E which are powerful antioxidants and helpful in the treatment of itchy, dehydrated skin.
- SOOTHES: The men’s lotion soothes inflamed and itchy areas, shaving rash and dry skin. The advanced formula is recommended for the treatment of accumulative skin damages caused by smoking, alcohol and stress. The shaving gel for men contains UV filters which protect your skin from sun damage and prevent aging.
- NATURAL INGREDIENTS: The shave gel contains natural ingredients, plant extracts and antioxidant vitamins. It’s the all-natural way to softer, smoother skin after shaving.
An Israeli made aftershave balm, it is known for helping to cure any irritation or redness caused by shaving.
Pros We Like
- Product lasts for a long time.
- Works well with sensitive skin.
- Doesn’t leave skin oily.
- A little bit of balm goes a long way.
- Handles irritations caused by shaving with ease.
- Product has a pleasant scent.
Cons We Dont Like
- There are occasional shipping problems.
- Low price, but the quality isn’t as great as the higher priced products.
Conclusion and our Top Picks for The Best Aftershave Balms
All of the above aftershave balms are very high quality products, but one has to come out on top. The best kind of aftershave balm has a good consistency, works well with any type of skin (especially sensitive skin), help treat irritations after shaving, have an affordable cost, and helps your skin feel healthier and moisturized.
#1
- long lasting
- great scent
- no burning sensation
- softens skin
- fantastic for sensitive skin
#2
- Reduces razor burn
- pleasant scent
- long lasting, great for sensitive skin
#3
- great for sensitive skin.
Of the above choices, I would have to say that Calvin Klein’s OBSESSION is my number one choice. When you look at the plethora of benefits it provides, it’s a bit of a no brainer, to me at least. Though the price is a bit higher than some of the others, the cost is well worth what you’ll be getting. All in all, the higher cost is really only a minute negative in comparison to some of the other negatives you could be dealing with.
When compared to the other products, it has far fewer issues and what issues it does have are far less of an issue. It is not known for having any issues with consistency, the scent is not known to fade quicker than advertised, and the balm last a nice length of time, a nice plus considering it is a little more expensive.
However, if you just simply aren’t convinced, I am happy to let you know what my second and third choices are.
If I had to choose what I believe to be the runner up to Calvin Klein’s OBSESSION, I would probably say it is Taylor of Old Bond Street. Don’t be fooled by the fact that it has four cons listed. If you look closely, the cons are minor details while the pros cover almost everything you would want in a balm.
Compared to some of the other balms, it has far more benefits and, if the price is what stopping you from purchasing Calvin Klein’s balm, you’ll be happy to see that it cost less. The Old Bond Street balm is clearly a great second choice.
But, if you still aren’t convinced, my third choice would probably be the Health and Beauty Dead Sea aftershave balm. Both are slightly less quality compared to my top two choices, but they cost less and you are still getting a quality balm that will do the job well, you just happen to be paying less money. This might be the best choice for you if you aren’t willing to spend a lot of money for your after shave treatment.
Whether you choose one of my top recommendations, a different one from the list, or one that didn’t even make it onto my list, I will always encourage anyone who is shaving to treat their face with care by implementing the use of aftershave in their routine.
Let me know what you think in the comments below, I’d love to hear from you. And, of course, feel free to share this article with anyone and everyone!
Happy shaving!
Loved the article? Why not check out more of our shaving articles or if you want, you can see more from shaving product reviews
